“Banba” marks a significant chapter in Clannad’s musical journey, showcasing their distinctive blend of Celtic folk and soft rock. In this latest endeavor, the band leans back towards their roots, a refreshing change; however, the selection still leans heavily towards accessible pop tunes designed for mass appeal. While some of the pop tracks may feel somewhat outdated, the songwriting here often reveals genuine emotion, contrasting with their previous releases.
Mel Collins contributes saxophone to multiple tracks, enriching the album’s textural dynamics, while synthesizers remain prominent, albeit somewhat incongruent with the folk style. Acoustic guitars continue to provide an authentic backdrop to the music. The album features one traditional Celtic song alongside two original pieces sung in their native language, with the remainder performed in English—save for a refrain in Native American in the track “I Will Find You.” The emotional weight feels variable; some songs resonate deeply while others maintain a more manufactured quality. Yet, the harmonies presented are largely beautiful and believable.
The original piece “Na Laethe Bhi” opens the album with lush, processed harmonies supported by minimal synthesizer backing. Its slow, reflective tempo departs from the typical album opener, establishing a traditional essence. An instrumental break introduces a more authentic sound but maintains minimalism, allowing the rich vocals to dominate.
“Banba Oir,” on the other hand, adopts a contemporary cadence with an upbeat feel, featuring saxophone and synth, and is sung in the traditional language, celebrating Ireland. Following this, “There for You” introduces English lyrics, marked by a mellow tone that is propelled forward by the saxophone.
“Mystery Game” showcases a minimalistic approach, presenting a more distinctive melody compared to its predecessors. This track offers a thoughtful alternative to the pop conventions of its time. “Struggle” shifts gears with a more energetic arrangement driven by acoustic and electric guitars, though its chorus may seem complicated. A brief guitar solo pays homage to David Gilmour’s style.
“I Will Find You” stands out as a key track, renowned from the film “Last of the Mohicans.” Its emotional depth shines through a lush arrangement, featuring heartfelt melodies complemented by harmonies, with a refrain in the tribal language.
“Soul Searcher,” featuring a guest male vocalist, diversifies the album’s auditory experience. Driven by acoustic guitar, with saxophone fulfilling predictable roles, it includes a captivating instrumental guitar interlude. “Caide Sin Do’n Te Sin” is the album’s sole traditional song, built upon acoustic guitar and piano, reflecting enduring folk tales. “The Other Side” springs forth as an upbeat track, characterized by intertwined harmonies and an acoustic interlude, representing one of their superior pop offerings.
“Sunset Dreams,” penned by Noel Duggan rather than Ciaran Brennan, delivers a basic composition that feels overly relaxed, lacking a sense of direction. The album concludes with “A Gentle Place,” which is an instrumental piece that spotlights the flute alongside supportive acoustic guitar.
Though this album may not quite reach the heights of Clannad’s earlier works, it approaches their foundational sound. It maintains a predominantly minimalist approach while occasionally venturing into pop territory. The construction of songs here proves to be an improvement, yet the overall output can be classified as good, rather than great, with memorable highlights for dedicated fans and those who enjoy soft, lush rock.
